Drug possession accounts for 39% of prison growth

An Idaho Office of Performance Evaluations report released in November 2026 found that drug possession sentences accounted for 39% of the state's prison growth. That was more than any other offense, according to the East Idaho News account. Both the East Idaho News account and the Idaho Capital Sun report describe drug possession as a major driver of prison growth.

The 39% figure covers growth since 2005, not the share of people entering prison in a given year, the East Idaho News account reported. The watchdog examined adult felony offenders under the Idaho Department of Correction's jurisdiction, using data that mostly covered 2005 through 2025, according to the report.

The OPE report PDF.

Prison growth came as custody for property crimes and younger offenders declined. Growth in drug offenses filled beds those trends had freed, according to the Office of Performance Evaluations.

Women's custody growth is closely tied to possession cases

The East Idaho News report quoted the watchdog report: "More than half of the growth of women in custody over the past two decades comes from women convicted of a single drug possession charge."

The number of women in custody had more than doubled over two decades. Idaho's female custody rate was the highest nationally in 2023, according to the report.

The Idaho Capital Sun reported that 22% of women in Idaho prisons had one drug possession sentence, compared with 10% of men. Among women in prison, 61% had drug possession sentences. The figure for men was 35%, according to the watchdog's findings.

Among the drug court users researchers analyzed, methamphetamine was the most commonly reported drug, at 48%. Heroin and other opioids followed at 20%, the Capital Sun reported. These figures describe drug court users, not the full prison population.

Idaho's custody rate rose in national rankings

Idaho had the highest incarceration rate in the Mountain West, according to the East Idaho News and Capital Sun reports.

Approximately 8,000 people are incarcerated across the statewide system's nine state-owned prisons and five community reentry centers, the East Idaho News account reported. Four counties accounted for 87% of the growth in the state's inmate population: Ada, Canyon, Kootenai and Twin Falls, the Capital Sun reported.

Probation violations can lead people into custody

People convicted of first-time drug possession rarely receive long-term custody sentences at the outset, the report says. Many receive probation or a short period in custody while a judge retains jurisdiction. About one-third of people diverted from a long-term sentence violate supervision and eventually enter custody, according to the Office of Performance Evaluations.

Prison growth includes people who enter custody after supervision violations, according to the report. About half of people on parole have returned to custody at least once before their term expires, according to the OPE report PDF.

A 2022 book chapter on drug policy reforms argues that reforms focused on reducing possession penalties have had limited effects on arrests and incarceration. It says reducing confinement for drug distribution could have a larger impact, and drug courts may be increasing rather than reducing arrests and incarceration (The Limits of Recent Drug Policy Reforms). The analysis concerns drug policy generally, not Idaho's specific data.

Lawmakers ordered more analysis

The November report made no policy recommendations. A bipartisan group of lawmakers requested it to examine prison growth. The Joint Legislative Oversight Committee later ordered a follow-up report, the Capital Sun reported.

At the report's release, Idaho House Minority Leader Ilana Rubel asked how mandatory minimums affected possession cases. Senior evaluator Christopher Shank said, "The majority of people that we looked at with drug offenses generally had possession charges that weren't impacted by mandatory minimums," according to the Capital Sun.

If property crime or the incarceration of younger people rises without a corresponding decline in drug-related custody, Idaho's system could face greater strain, the Office of Performance Evaluations said.